Banned Books Week gets me fired up every year, and that passion has only grown since last year’s Curious Incident Incident.
Since 2014, I have participated in the Banned Books Week Virtual Readout (which, by the way, can be done anytime — not just during BBW). In 2014, I read from Captain Underpants; in 2015 I read from The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time, and this year I read from Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out.
I am a bit of a newbie when it comes to “clipping” passages via Audible, and I found the passages I had intended to share in my readout, after the readout. I want to expand on those a bit (the read-out is limited to 3 minutes) before I pass the paper version of the book along to a friend.
Other Important Passages
The three passages I shared were from:
Jessy, who was born as a girl and now identifies as a male. Jessy spoke about how he enjoys life “from a different perspective.”
I can see the world simultaneously from a male and a female perspective. ~ Jessy
Wanda, mom of Jonathan, who is gay and Christina, who is transsexual. As a parent, Wanda’s statements really resonated with me.
Hug your children. Hug them. ~ Wanda
Luke, who was born as a girl and now identifies as a male, and whose poem inspired the title of the book. Luke said coming out trans is “very exposing. It opens you up to a lot of mockery.” It was important to Luke to come out via a poem.
Said, ‘What are you?’ said, ‘you gotta choose’
said, ‘Pink or blue?’
and I said I’m a real nice color of magenta.
The passages I couldn’t find due to my Audible clip-finding incompetence and the ones I did not have space for are:
Wanda, Jonathan’s and Christina’s mom (again). [in response to a man who had physically attacked Christina]: “You’re not from here, right? In America people are used to this. There are gays, there are lesbians, there’s transgender. There are all kinds.”
Wanda continues, “…when I’m in the train with her, I still hear little kids say, ‘Mom, is that a man or a woman?’ I don’t want to hear that. I sometimes have to remind her not to show her Adam’ apple, and that’s so sad. I don’t want to have to remind her to keep her chin down.”
These passages about Wanda’s response to the man who had attacked Christina, and about the interactions she and Christina have with strangers on the train, resonated with me. I think it was because Wanda had an opportunity to educate the man who had attacked Christina (obviously it’s horrible that an attack is what led to that educational moment). Secondly, talking about the train made me think of how we can jump to assumptions about one another and the absolutely moronic (and hurtful) things people can say to one another when silence would be a better choice (but I understand that kids ask filter-less questions…).
Mariah, who was born as a boy but is transitioning to female: “A lot of transgender girls feel that they look like a boy and they try to fix it. The thing is, real beauty comes from the inside. You could be the most passable trans woman ever. Real beauty from the inside!”
The thing is, real beauty comes from the inside. ~ Mariah
I just loved this because …. it’s so very true.
Cameron, who was born as a girl and, at this point, requests to be referred to with pronouns such as “they, them, and their” talked about being treated with male privilege: Because I’m perceived as a male, I get male privileges. Male privilege means I don’t have to prove myself for my opinion to have weight. People assume that I’m intelligent. People assume that I have something to say. I get a fair amount of respect.
Cameron continues, “By being male, I’m automatically given some kind of validity that is weird. ‘Wait, guys, I haven’t said anything yet. And besides, you shouldn’t be giving me male privilege because I’m not really a guy — at least not by your standards, I’m definitely not.”
Why did this section intrigue me? Honestly it’s because there have been a few times in my life when I wouldn’t have minded just a few moments of “male privilege” when I was treated condescendingly.
A Few Closing Thoughts About This Book and This Topic
This book gave me insights into being transgender that I have not had previously. At the same time, as a parent, I found myself mentally sorting out some dynamics that were specific to teenagerhood and family dysfunction. It must make teenagerhood, which is already fraught with its share of difficulties, even harder to be so misunderstood.
In all honesty, though, I struggled with pieces of the book. Maybe it’s because my journey of understanding what it is to transition and to be transgender is fairly new. I do see why teens who want to supplement their transition with hormones and/or surgery have to go through intensive counseling. I heard their impatience to “just move things along” and worried that they had not developed the critical thinking skills and self awareness necessary to make such life-changing decisions.
I guess no book about such a heavy topic SHOULD be neatly tied up with a perfect bow. That’s why I feel so strongly about access to all kinds of books, and am such a staunch advocate for the freedom to read.
AND … I have to commend author Susan Kuklin for her photography skills as well. Perhaps Audible has that stuff in “the files” (those things I never look at after reading an audiobook) but it was a special pleasure to hold the pages (and images) in my hands, especially the ones at my beloved NYC High Line!
A Great Banned Books Week Video
I thought this video from Phillips Academy Andover (which mentions Beyond Magenta, I might add!), was creative!
Their summary statement echoes my position pretty well:
In honor of #BannedBooksWeek, the Oliver Wendell Holmes Library and Phillips Academy encourage students to read and obtain knowledge from all sources. At Andover we believe in the First Amendment and that we should not censor what is available to our students.
Wife of one, Mom of two, Friend of many. My pronouns are she/her/hers.
Alana Mautone (@RamblinGarden) says
Yes, I read banned books, although not in a particular week. My favorite, besides The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night time, is The Absolutely True Diary Of A Part Time Indian. I have The Glass Castle at home somewhere (buried in my hundreds of books) perhaps that will be my choice for this year.
Paula Kiger says
I haven’t read the Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian. I did read Glass Castle — such a luminously written book. I hope you get to it! Thanks for commenting.
Janice Wald says
When I used to teach English, the best way to motivate a child to read is by telling them they are reading a book banned in other places in the country.
Sad that censorship still exists.
Paula Kiger says
Isn’t that the absolute truth? And so true re: motivating kids in many areas of life!
I really thought by now, we’d be done with the banning.
Paula Kiger says
Wouldn’t you think? I think it’s important that the ALA (American Library Association) watches out for challenges as well, not just banning. There are baby steps that look sort of innocuous but begin to erode freedom of expression and it’s important (to me) to speak out against those as well as outright banning.
Thanks for inspiring me to go find a banned book to read on the subway! http://www.ala.org/bbooks/BannedBooksWeek
Paula Kiger (Big Green Pen) says
AWESOME! Let me know what you choose and what you think!